elderly man with a neck brace signing papers with his lawyer

When you’ve been hurt and it’s someone else’s fault — for example, a car accident, a fall on someone else’s property, a medical error or a defective product — you may need to bring a personal injury lawsuit to cover your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering and other losses. It’s tough to decide whether to fight the case in court or settle the claim.

The most important thing to do before you decide whether to settle your case is to talk with a qualified attorney. Your lawyer will investigate all the circumstances of your situation and evaluate how likely you are to win the case – and how much money a judge or jury might award you.

Your attorney will also reach out to the defendants and determine how willing they are to fight the case. Sometimes defendants – and their insurance companies – refuse to be reasonable in their negotiations, making it very difficult to settle a case without giving up more than you should.

In the end, the decision on whether to settle depends on how strong your case is and how much each side is willing to fight. Another important consideration is how much insurance coverage is available from the responsible parties.

When It May Be Best to Fight in Court

If the evidence clearly shows that the defendant was at fault and your losses were clearly far more than what the insurance company is offering, it may be worthwhile to take your claim to court.

It’s important to remember, though, that there is always a risk in letting a judge or jury decide your claim. Even if you think your case is a “sure thing,” it is still possible that the court will see it differently and find for the defendant. 

When It May Be Best to Settle

South Carolina uses a modified comparative negligence system. This means that you may be able to recover compensation even if you were partly to blame for your accident. However, if the evidence arguably shows fault on your part, it may not be worth risking a trial – especially if the insurance company has made a reasonable offer to settle.

This is where advice from a trusted lawyer can be very important. Your lawyer is not emotionally involved in the case the way you are and will be impartial when it comes to giving advice about whether to take a settlement offer. Of course, it is ultimately your decision.

Another factor to consider is whether you can wait for a case to make its way through the courts. People with high medical bills or other expenses may want to settle faster to recover needed funds.

How Soon Do I Need to Make a Decision?

In South Carolina, the statute of limitations for filing an injury claim is three years in most cases. The time limit can be shorter if the at-fault party was a government entity.

It’s important to start the process as soon as possible in order to prepare the best case and protect your interests to the fullest possible extent. An attorney will help you understand the laws so that you are equipped to take legal action, either immediately or once you are further along in your recovery.

Keep in mind that filing a case in court does not rule out a settlement. In fact, many cases settle during the pre-trial phase, on the courthouse steps or even during trial.

About the Author

Since 1968, the South Carolina personal injury and workers’ compensation attorneys of Joye Law Firm have been committed to securing compensation for accident and injury victims. Our compassionate and dedicated lawyers have over 300 years of combined litigation experience, and many of them have been recognized as South Carolina Super Lawyers. For many years, our South Carolina personal injury law firm has been listed with an AV rating in the prestigious Martindale-Hubbell legal directory.

Recent Blog Post
texting while driving
South Carolina Hands-Free and Distracted Driving Act Aims to Prevent Collisions

A new South Carolina law outlaws the use of handheld mobile electronic devices while driving. Taking effect on September 1st, 2025, the South Carolina Hands-Free and Distracted Driving Act aims to raise awareness and decrease the number of accidents caused…

2026 Best Lawyers in America Joye Law Firm attorneys included for selection
Multiple Attorneys at Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers Included in The Best Lawyers in America

We are proud to share that 19 attorneys from Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers have been selected for inclusion in the 2026 edition of The Best Lawyers in America® and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch®. Additionally, the firm’s Managing Partner,…

Intersection Accidents and Injuries in South Carolina
How Our Attorneys Handle a Liberty Mutual Claim

After an accident, getting the insurance company to pay what’s fair can be more frustrating than the crash itself. That’s especially true when dealing with a Liberty Mutual claim. Liberty Mutual is one of the country’s largest auto insurance companies,…

A car crash on the street with visibly damaged vehicles.
How Our Attorneys Handle a Progressive Claim

Progressive is one of the largest auto insurers in the country, known for quick claim turnarounds. But that speed doesn’t always work in your favor. Their adjusters are trained to limit payouts and close files fast. If you’re dealing with…

Awards & Recognition
Media
ABC
NBC
Fox
CBS News
ESPN Radio logo