Insurance company Image

Auto insurance is legally required for all drivers in South Carolina. Auto insurance experts, according to their own data, say that the average driver will be involved in a car accident roughly once every 18 years. That means most drivers are going nearly two decades at a stretch regularly paying a significant amount of money each and every month to insurance companies without getting anything back for it.

So, when drivers do get into wrecks, they expect their insurance to do what it’s supposed to do and pay for their medical bills and for their cars to be repaired. But insurance companies are out to make money, and paying you isn’t how they do it.

When an insurance company refuses to pay a policy holder compensation on a legitimate claim, that’s what’s called a bad faith insurance claim. “Bad faith” means dishonest dealing, because the insurance company is breaking their end of the bargain.

What Are Ways Insurance Companies Show “Bad Faith?”

Insurance companies show bad faith by withholding benefits that policyholders are entitled to, or by withholding benefits for unreasonable reasons.

Examples might be:

  • Failing to respond to a claim request promptly
  • Misinterpreting the language in an insurance contract to get out of paying a claim
  • Failing to disclose policy limits or exclusions when selling policies
  • Failing to properly investigate a policyholder’s claim
  • Making unreasonable demands on the policyholder to prove a covered loss
  • Ignoring evidence that supports a policyholder’s claim
  • Failing to pay out on a claim promptly when liability is clear, or any unreasonable delay in paying a claim

If My Settlement Is Too Low, Does That Count as Bad Faith?

If it’s simply a difference in opinion between you and the adjuster about what your claim is worth, it likely isn’t a bad faith claim. That doesn’t mean you can’t push to receive more money with the help of an experienced personal injury lawyer handling the negotiations for you after an accident.

However, if the insurance adjuster fails to provide any supporting evidence for how they made their estimate, or ignores evidence that supports your estimate over theirs, it may be a bad faith claim after all. We recommend speaking with an experienced South Carolina personal injury lawyer to see if yours might be a bad faith claim.

An insurance carrier’s failure to act in good faith on a policyholder’s claim gave rise to a bad faith action after repeated delays and an unreasonably low offer. The firm pursued the matter beyond the initial coverage dispute and ultimately resolved the case for a confidential settlement. For a detailed account of this case, read the full case study.

Can I Only Make a Bad Faith Claim Against My Auto Insurance Provider?

No, insurance providers can and do break faith on all kinds of policies, including health insurance, homeowners’ insurance, and so on.

What Do I Do When an Insurance Company Acts in Bad Faith?

When an insurance company refuses to hold to the terms of your contract, the first thing you should do is contact a lawyer.

A lawyer can get the ball rolling with a bad faith letter requesting the insurance company state their position in writing on why your claim was reduced or denied, and file a lawsuit if necessary.

In a bad faith lawsuit, you may be eligible for not only your damages from the accident, but also for consequential damages, your attorney’s fees, and potentially even punitive damages.

Do you suspect the insurance company has been acting in bad faith after an accident that left you injured? Contact Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers today for a free case review.

About the Author

Since 1968, the South Carolina personal injury and workers’ compensation attorneys of Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers have been committed to securing compensation for accident and injury victims. Our compassionate and dedicated lawyers have over 300 years of combined litigation experience, and many of them have been recognized as South Carolina Super Lawyers. For many years, our South Carolina personal injury law firm has been listed with an AV rating in the prestigious Martindale-Hubbell legal directory.

Recent Blog Post
Best Law Firm Ranked by Best Lawyers 2027 in 6 regional Tier 1 rankings
Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers Selected for Best Law Firms® in America by Best Lawyers®

Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers is proud to announce that the firm has been selected for inclusion in 2027’s The Best Law Firms® in America by Best Lawyers®. This prestigious recognition reflects our ongoing commitment to excellence, client service, and…

Greenville Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers attorneys and case managers in the conference room
Private Equity in Law Firms: What It Means for Injury Clients

As private equity firms seek to diversify their portfolios, they are increasing their investments into personal injury law firms. While ethics rules still restrict non-lawyer ownership in most states, some places now allow new kinds of law firm ownership. Others…

What Is a Life Care Plan and Why Does Your Injury Case Need One?

You may need a “life care plan” after a spinal cord injury, traumatic brain injury, amputation, or another lasting condition. The care plan is a roadmap for your future care, and it can play a big role in your personal…

warehouse worker injury
Do I Have to Use FMLA While on Workers’ Comp?

One of the most common questions injured workers ask is, “Do I have to use FMLA while I’m on workers’ comp?” A workplace injury can affect every part of your life at once and turn it upside down. Suddenly, you’re…

Awards & Recognition
Media
ABC
NBC
Fox
CBS News
ESPN Radio logo