doctor giving medical advice about workers comp to a couple

If you were injured at work in South Carolina, then you know how difficult the situation can be.

Unfortunately, this situation can become even more complicated if your doctor initially misdiagnosed your health condition or made a mistake during your medical examination.

South Carolina does not give those who were injured on the job the absolute right to get a second medical opinion on their work injury. However, especially in cases such as those where someone has an injury requiring surgery, there are many instances where a worker’s compensation insurance company will agree to set up a second opinion. If your employer denies you a second opinion, you should speak with a knowledgeable workers’ compensation attorney as soon as possible. The attorney will immediately begin the process to ensure that your rights are protected and aid you in pursuing all of the South Carolina workers’ compensation benefits you are entitled to, including setting up a second opinion medical examination with an independent doctor.

Here, we explain crucial aspects of the process that goes into seeking a second medical opinion.

Initial Medical Examinations

In all cases other than medical emergencies, you are initially required to get a medical exam from a doctor that your employer or its workers’ compensation insurer has approved.

An employer will usually request that you see a doctor who typically sees the company’s injured workers and who is already included under the company’s workers’ compensation plan. The doctor who performs this initial examination could decide a worker’s course of treatment and disability level. Thus, the doctor who is chosen for your initial examination is very important .

One of the doctor’s main roles is to decide whether or not the employee’s injury was, in fact, caused by their job activities. In order to receive workers’ compensation benefits in South Carolina, your injury must have occurred within the scope and course of your job.

The doctor might also:

  • Diagnose your injury or condition
  • Determine a treatment plan for you
  • Make an assessment as to when your condition allows you to resume work
  • Decide what duties you are able to fulfill with your condition
  • Give you an impairment rating.

If you are not happy with the doctor that you are assigned for your initial examination and you wish to receive a second opinion, you need to discuss this with your employer or its insurance carrier. If your employer or their insurer denies your request to receive a second physician’s opinion, a knowledgeable South Carolina workers’ compensation attorney can help you navigate this issue.

When Should I Ask for a Second Medical Opinion?

There are two situations in which an injured worker may wish to receive a second medical opinion:

During the Initial Examination

During an initial examination, the doctor assigned by the employer or its workers’ compensation insurer will try to diagnose a worker’s condition or injury. In some cases, the worker may not feel comfortable with the physician’s diagnosis or treatment plan, or the injured worker may feel that the physician performed an insufficient examination.

During the Impairment Rating Determination

An employer’s insurer may also require that an injured worker receives an examination to decide whether or not he or she has reached Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI). If the assigned doctor determines that the injured worker is not likely to keep improving their health condition with continued treatment, the doctor may give the worker an impairment rating. An impairment rating is a major factor in determining how much an injured worker will receive in permanent disability payments.

For example, if a doctor’s opinion would support an employee’s claim that he is totally disabled, the injured party may receive benefits payments for up to 500 weeks of an amount that is equal to two-thirds of his or her average weekly wage (or up to the statutory maximum weekly benefit).

So, if you are an injured worker who believes that the insurance company or employer-selected physician did not perform a satisfactory examination or failed to fully address the extent of your permanent impairment, you may need to seek a second opinion.

Obtaining a Second Opinion

If your employer or its insurer agrees to your obtaining a second opinion, anything that the second physician discovers during your second exam must be shared with the insurance company, the original doctor, and your employer. Despite the fact that employer is able to choose your initial doctor, they do not have the right to speak with that doctor about the worker’s case unless they obtain permission from the worker. However, the employer does have the right to ask for medical reports and to send the doctor written questions, as long as the written questions are copied and provided to either the injured worker, or the worker’s lawyer. Injured workers also have the right to be present whenever a case manager speaks with either the doctor or other medical personnel who are involved in their case.

An Experienced Workers’ Compensation Lawyer Can Help You

If you were hurt on the job and you are not happy with any aspect of the initial examination and/or treatment you were given by the insurance company-selected physician, you should contact a South Carolina workers’ compensation lawyer immediately. An experienced lawyer will help you navigate the proper process of obtaining a second medical opinion.

Contact Joye Law Firm today to learn more. At Joye Law Firm, you will find experienced workers’ compensation attorneys who will give you advice about your rights and options in a confidential consultation, free of charge.

About the Author

Ken Harrell joined Joye Law Firm in 1994, and has been the managing partner since 2006. With 30 years of experience, he protects the rights of injured South Carolinians, including cases involving workers’ compensation, car accidents, and defective products. Ken also leads the firm’s referral practice, helping to ensure that our clients receive the best possible representation. He is a past president of South Carolina Injured Workers’ Advocates, and has served as the co-chairman of this organization’s legislative affairs committee for 12 years.

Recent Blog Post
What to do in South Carolina? Events for the week of July 23 - 29 in Charleston, Summerville, Columbia, Myrtle Beach, and Upstate SC.
What to Do in South Carolina: Joye Law Firm Staff Picks 7/23/24 – 7/29/24

As July is coming to a close, South Carolina is brimming with exciting events that cater to a variety of interests. Whether you’re a vintage enthusiast, a foodie, a Christmas connoisseur, an animal lover, or a car aficionado, there’s something…

What to do in South Carolina? Events for the week of July 16 - 22 in Charleston, Summerville, Columbia, Myrtle Beach, and Upstate SC.
What to Do in South Carolina: Joye Law Firm Staff Picks 7/16/24 – 7/22/24

  This week, South Carolina is buzzing with exciting events across the state. The Joye Law Firm team has curated a list of must-attend events that promise fun, entertainment, and celebration of culture. Whether you’re into food festivals, live music,…

Lawyers preparing for hearing
What to Expect at a Workers’ Comp Hearing in South Carolina?

News flash – insurance companies love saying “no” to paying benefits. Many of our workers’ compensation clients reached out to us after getting a denial letter from their employer’s workers’ comp carrier. If this happens to you, don’t just accept…

Hammer gavel judge and US dollar banknote money with car vehicle accident
How Much Does a Lawyer Cost for a Car Accident?

After a car accident, you likely have a lot on your plate. On top of the pain and uncertainty from your injuries, you’re dealing with the added stress of car repairs, hospital bills, and time away from work. Many people…

Awards & Recognition
Media
ABC
NBC
Fox
CBS News
ESPN Radio logo