On This page
    Potholes in South Carolina

    Every South Carolinian knows many of our local roadways suffer from neglect and poor maintenance. While we’ve all driven around a pothole or two, for bicyclists or pedestrians, a road defect can go from annoying to an actual safety threat, and someone needs to be held responsible. If your crash was caused by an unsafe roadway and not operator error, a South Carolina road defect accident lawyer can help. A lawyer can advocate for the compensation you’re owed by investigating who controlled the road, how long the hazard existed, whether earlier complaints were made, and whether reasonable repairs or warnings were provided.

    Road defects endanger motorcyclists, bicyclists, and even pedestrians. Depending on the location and circumstances, the responsible party may be a state or local agency, a road contractor, a utility company, another entity, or some combination of those parties. Because the applicable procedures and deadlines can depend on who maintained the roadway, obtaining an early legal review can be important for injured victims to protect evidence early on and understand their legal options in a premises liability claim.

    For bicyclists in particular, defects that may have little effect on a motor vehicle can cause a devastating crash. A pothole, abrupt pavement change, damaged shoulder, loose gravel, or other unsafe surface can cause a cyclist to lose control or be thrown from their bike. In one case handled by Joye Law Firm Injury lawyers, a client was thrown from her bicycle after hitting a pothole. The impact caused massive internal bleeding and injuries so severe that approximately 80% of her small intestine had to be removed. Cases like this demonstrate how a seemingly ordinary road defect can have life-changing consequences.

    If you’re facing serious injuries due to road defects, you might feel outgunned and unmatched against a government entity, big business, or their insurance company. Let our South Carolina premises liability lawyers at Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers level the playing field for you. We can identify who maintained the road, preserve evidence, and explain your legal options during a free consultation.

    Who Is Liable for a Road Defect Accident

    Who is liable for a road hazard accident depends on who controlled the location, who had the duty to maintain it, and how the dangerous road condition developed. The name on a road sign or the city in the mailing address may not answer that question. Maintenance agreements, route records, permits, and contracts can help identify the responsible party. Some of the common entities include:

    1. SCDOT: The South Carolina Department of Transportation may be responsible for a state-maintained highway or another road in the state system.
    2. A city: A municipality may maintain a city street, traffic signal, marking, or other public way.
    3. A county: A county may control a road in an unincorporated area or have a maintenance agreement for a particular location.
    4. A contractor: A private contractor may share responsibility if its construction, repair work, equipment, or road debris created the hazard.
    5. A neighborhood HOA: A homeowners’ association may be responsible for maintaining private roads, sidewalks, signs, lighting, or other common areas within a community.
    6. A business: A business or property owner, such as a shopping center, may be responsible for hazards on privately owned roads, parking lots, sidewalks, or entrances.

    More than one party may be involved. Identifying the correct at-fault party early matters because a claim sent to the wrong office may not protect your rights.

    Common Road Defects That Cause Accidents

    In dangerous road conditions accidents, people can still be hurt even when no motor vehicles are involved. Common hazards include:

    1. Potholes and broken pavement: A bicycle wheel can drop into a hole or catch a sharp pavement edge, throwing the rider forward and causing traumatic brain injuries, fractures, spinal cord injuries, internal injuries, or severe road rash.
    2. Uneven or Dangerous Road Surfaces: Abrupt changes in pavement height, sunken areas, raised sections, poorly maintained shoulders, and other surface irregularities can create dangerous conditions for bicyclists. Even relatively small defects can destabilize a cyclist traveling at speed.
    3. Poor Drainage and Standing Water: Inadequate drainage can allow water to collect on a roadway, bicycle path, parking lot, or other riding surface. Standing water may conceal potholes and other defects while creating slippery conditions that increase the risk of a crash.
    4. Faded markings: Worn out lane lines, bicycle-lane markings, and crosswalks can make the intended path hard to see.
    5. Unsafe construction zones: Open cuts, uneven temporary surfaces, and missing warnings may put a contractor, a government entity, or both under scrutiny.

    Uncleared debris: Gravel, loose materials, branches, or construction waste can cause a rider to lose traction or swerve.

    What to Do After a Road-Defect Accident

    1. Seek medical attention. Call 911 when needed and get medical care even if pain seems manageable. Sometimes a concussion, internal injuries, or other serious injuries that are not obvious at the accident scene.
    2. Report the incident. Ask law enforcement to document the location and what happened. Get the report number and the responding agency’s information.
    3. Photograph the defect and surrounding area. If it is safe, take wide and close views that show the pothole’s position, depth, broken edges, nearby signs, lane markings, and the direction you were traveling. Place a familiar object near the defect for scale without disturbing the scene.
    4. Record the exact location. Save the street name, route number, nearest address or intersection, travel direction, lane, GPS coordinates, and time. Small location errors can send an investigation to the wrong agency.
    5. Preserve witnesses and physical evidence. Get witness contact details. Bicyclists should keep the bicycle, helmet, clothing, damaged phone, repair estimates, and original photo files. Do not repair or discard key items before your legal team can inspect them.
    6. Limit recorded statements and public posts. An insurance company or government adjuster may request a statement. Get legal advice before discussing fault or injuries, and avoid posting about the event or your recovery.
    7. Contact an accident lawyer quickly. Early legal representation can help preserve records, identify the proper defendant, and protect the short government-claim timeline.

    South Carolina follows modified comparative negligence. Your compensation can be reduced by your share of fault, and recovery is barred if your fault is greater than 50%. A rider’s speed, visibility, route choice, or attention may be disputed, so objective scene evidence matters.

    Suing the Government: The South Carolina Tort Claims Act

    We get calls all the time asking, “Can I sue the city for a pothole?” The answer is complicated. That’s because the rules are different for lawsuits against a governmental entity than they are for ones against a private person or business. The South Carolina Tort Claims Act, found in Title 15, Chapter 78 of the South Carolina Code, provides a limited exception to the government’s usual protection from lawsuits. Governmental entities may be liable for torts subject to the Act’s limits and exceptions.

    Section 15-78-60(15) is especially important in road defect cases. It addresses signs, signals, warnings, guardrails, and certain defects on public ways. Depending on how the dangerous condition arose, liability may turn in part on whether the government entity responsible for maintaining the area had actual or constructive notice of the condition and failed to correct it withing a reasonable time. The statute also contains specific protections for responsible government entities, including provisions addressing highway design and public ways under construction. For that reason, maintenance claim, construction claim, and design claim therefore require different analysis.

    For most non-medical claims under the Act, current Section 15-78-120 generally limits recovery to $300,000 for one person’s loss from a single occurrence and $600,000 in total for a single occurrence. Punitive or exemplary damages and prejudgment interest are not available under the Act. These limits and exceptions require attorney confirmation before publication and before anyone values a personal injury claim.

    Recoverable actual damages may include medical bills, future medical costs, lost wages, lost income, pain and suffering, and damage to a vehicle/bicycle or other tangible property, subject to the evidence and applicable limits. Insurance coverage may also affect the sources of compensation, so the full policy picture should be reviewed.

    You Must Prove the Government Knew

    A photograph of a pothole proves that a defect existed at one moment. It does not, by itself, prove that the responsible agency knew about it in time to act. Notice is often the central dispute in a road defect claim.

    Actual notice may come from an earlier complaint, a maintenance request, a police report, an employee’s observation, or a prior inspection. Constructive notice means the facts may show the defect existed long enough, or was visible enough, that the responsible entity should have discovered it through reasonable care.

    Useful evidence may include dated photographs or video, 911 records, prior crash reports, inspection logs, repair schedules, work orders, complaint histories, construction records, and witness accounts about how long the pothole was present. Weather data and the physical condition of the broken pavement may also help establish a timeline. Some records can change or be overwritten, which is one reason to gather evidence promptly.

    The Deadlines Are Shorter: Act Fast

    Unlike other personal injury claims that have a three-year Statute of Limitations (time in which an injured individual must bring a claim and/or file an action), claims against governmental entities must be made within two years.

    How Joye Law Firm Can Help

    Road defect injury claims require work beyond sending medical bills to an insurance adjuster. Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers can determine whether SCDOT, a city, a county, a contractor, or multiple parties controlled the site. We can launch a full investigation to seek maintenance and complaint records, examine the defect with qualified professionals, interview witnesses, document medical expenses and lost income, and calculate your future care needs.

    Our work for injured people has also earned recognition from the legal community. In the 2026 Best Law Firms® rankings, our personal injury practice was selected for Regional Tier 1 rankings for personal injury litigation for plaintiffs in Charleston and Columbia. That same year, Attorney Mark Joye, who leads our Litigation Department, and Attorney Jeff Gerardi were among our attorneys selected for the South Carolina Super Lawyers for personal injury work. These distinctions reflect peer and client regard for the advocacy and service we strive to provide in every injury case.

    Our proven approach and core values guide everything we do. We are committed to acting compassion, bravery, continuous improvement, and respect for the greater good. We believe in providing exceptional client service and explaining the legal process in plain language so injured clients can make informed decisions.

    Our clients get our No Fee Guarantee. We provide legal representation on a contingency fee basis, which means you won’t pay any attorney fees unless we get a recovery for you. We explain the fee agreement and case-cost terms in detail before you hire us. No lawyer can promise a fair settlement or maximum compensation, but an experienced attorney can build the evidence needed to pursue compensation allowed by South Carolina law.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Road Defects

    Can I sue the city for a pothole?

    You may have a claim if the city maintained the road, owed a duty, and failed to address the pothole under the applicable standards. City limits alone do not prove city control. Records must also support notice, causation, injuries, and damages. Government immunities and deadlines can still limit the claim.

    Who maintains the road?

    It may be SCDOT, a city, a county, another public body, a private contractor, or some combination. Route numbers, ownership maps, maintenance agreements, work permits, and project contracts can help answer the question. Do not rely only on the street name or the agency that took the first report.

    How long do I have to file?

    The current Act generally allows two years to bring a claim and/or file an action.

    Are damages capped?

    Generally, and in most cases, yes. The current statutory limits are $300,000 for one person’s loss from one occurrence and $600,000 total per occurrence. Punitive damages are unavailable under the Act.

    Talk to a South Carolina Road Defect Lawyer

    After a road-defect injury, the first useful question is not necessarily whether to sue. It is whether the circumstances deserve a closer look. At Joye Law Firm Injury Lawyers, we listen before we advise and give you a candid assessment of both the strengths and challenges we see. Contact us for a free consultation. Our goal in that first conversation is simple: to replace uncertainty with a clear next step, whether or not you ultimately have a case.

    Contact us
    Attorney Image